Best Pool Fence Reviews to Protect your Family 2017



An estimated 390 children (2013) under the age of five drown in swimming pools each year. To help prevent these tragedies, the first step should be installing the best pool fence for safety of your children and their little pool playmate guests, followed shortly by using a top pool alarm.


Best Pool Safety Fence Comparison

ModelEditor RatingPrice 
1. Pool Fence by Life Saver Fencing Section Kit 4 x 12-Feet
4.3 $$
2. Water Warden In Ground Pool Safety Fence 4' x 12' Section
4.2 $$
3. Pool Fence by EZ-Guard 4' 12'
4.3 $$
4. Classic Guard Swimming Pool Fence 4 Feet Tall and 12 Feet Long
4.2 $$
5. Protect-A-Pool Fence Base Kit A - 8 Section Base Kit
4.1 $$$

Buying guide


Safety requirements and regulations


"Drowning is the leading cause of unintentional death for children between the ages of 1 and 4 and minority children drown in pools at an alarming rate," said U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) Chairman Inez Tenenbaum. “The lives of countless children can be saved this summer. Take simple safety steps today—teach all children to swim, put a fence around all pools, and always watch children in and around the water.” Don't forget to use a quality life jacket.


The first factor to consider when buying the best pool fence for your swimming pool is the set of guidelines and codes developed by The Association of Pool & Spa Professionals and accepted by the American National Standards Institute:


  1. The fence must be a minimum of 48″ tall (or taller, depending on the distance between horizontal rails).

  2. The middle horizontal rail must be at least 45″ above the bottom horizontal rail (to prevent using the horizontal rails as a kind of ladder for climbing).

  3. The spacing between pickets must be less than 4″.

  4. If space between pickets is less than 1 3/4, rule #2 does not apply and the fence does not have to be taller than 48 (because the tighter picket spacing has made climbing much more difficult).

  5. The space between the bottom horizontal rail and the ground must be less than 2″.

  6. The gate(s) must be self-closing and self-latching.

  7. The gate(s) need to open out (away from the pool area).

  8. The opening mechanism of the latch must be at least 54″ above grade (ground level).


Installing a sturdy and well structured pool fence is not only a necessary security measure, but is in fact a legal and an insurance requirement in many areas around the US. Some of the States have particular regulations as regards pool fences and pool owners’ liabilities so do check those as well.


Common Best Swimming Pool Fence Types


In our best pool fence reviews, we’ll consider different fence types, materials, looks, efficiency of protection and ease of installation.


1. Removable Mesh Pool Fences

Removable mesh pool fences are one of the most popular for a few good reasons: they are transparent, easy to use and fully removable. Due to of security concerns, the mesh fences must meet the approval standards of the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM). This is mandatory in most states in the US so do check out the regulations before you buy them. They are basically posts of the appropriate height with the mesh stretched around them. As simple and as convenient as that. They are inexpensive, durable and easy to install.

2. Vertical Bar Fence

These fences can be made from a wide variety of materials such as iron, wood, vinyl, or aluminum. Wrought iron fences do not completely obstructing the view of the pool. Their biggest drawback is their susceptibility to rust over time. Wood fences come in a variety of options in terms of type of wood and color. The main disadvantage though is that the wooden bars obstruct the view of the pool.

3. Glass Panel Fence

These are made from tempered glass and are quite durable. They are transparent and don’t obstruct the view of your pool. They do have to be cleaned all the time and are rather expensive so not many pool owners can afford them.

In our pool safety fence reviews we mostly opted for removable mesh pool fences as they are affordable and widely accessible.

Best Pool Safety Fences Reviews


Editor Rating:

4.3/5

Pool Fence DIY by Life Saver is a do-it-yourself fencing kit which will keep children safe from unsupervised pool use or accidental falls into your pool. It features industrial-strength mesh fence at CPSC recommended height of 4 feet and is, overall, the best pool safety fence.

It includes 5 integrated poles with a 1/2-inch stainless steel pin. This fence is easy to install and it can be easily removed when no children are present and re-inserted when needed.


The package includes 12-foot section of fencing, 5 poles which are already assembled and attached, deck sleeves with caps and a safety latch. The installation will require a rotary hammer drill and a long shaft masonry bit which is not included in the kit.

Pool Fence by Life Saver Fencing Section Kit 4 x 12-Feet

The main line of defense of a Pool Fence DIY system is its mesh constructed of industrial-strength, Textilene PVC-coated nylon. It has a strength rating of over 270 pounds per square inch. The polyvinyl basket weave is infused with quality UV inhibitors. They will make your pool fence look great for years and provide durability in all weather conditions.

The five integrated posts are made of heavy gauge aluminum, and the kit comes with easy-to-follow instructions that make it easy to install the Pool Fence DIY. The posts are spaced every 36 inches. At the bottom, each post has a steel peg that slips into sleeves which you will place into drilled holes around your pool deck.

To calculate how much mesh you need, measure around the edge of your pool and leave about 40 inches of space for walking and cleaning. After determining your total footage, divide it by 12 to calculate the correct number of sections needed.

As for the drilling involved, if you are not sure you’ll be able to do it yourself or if you don’t have the tools, hire a handyman. This fence has a limited lifetime warranty. You will need to buy the gate separately.

Things We Liked


  • ​Stable construction
  • ​Ideal for kids’ protection
  • ​Easily removed when not needed
  • ​Quality and weather resistant materials

Things We Didn't Like


  • Not that easy to DIY

Price:

$$












Editor Rating:

4.2/5

Water Warden Safety Fence will keep your pool area secure with its reliable and sturdy materials. If you install it properly, you’ll have no worries about the little ones getting into the pool without your supervision. On top of that, it’s the best pool fence to keep the leaves out of your pool on windy days.

This fence is easily self-installed and the super-strong woven mesh will not allow children or pets to enter the pool area unsupervised. It has a climb-resistant mesh which doesn’t give children any toeholds or finger holds.

Water Warden Safety Fence is designed to be self-installed and needs 5/8-inch holes to be drilled in the deck. Make sure you drill perfectly straight holes at 90 degrees if you want your fence sections tight.

It takes some skill to install, however, and we suggest buying or renting a drilling guide if you don’t have one. A pair of helping hands will be appreciated. Alternatively, you can hire a handyman.

Water Warden In Ground Pool Safety Fence 4' x 12' Section

The safety fence can easily be removed and reinstalled in minutes by a single person. The lightweight fence rolls up when not in use for easy storage. The fence comes with plastic covers for the postholes when the fence is not in use.

It comes in pre-assembled 4-inch in height by 12-inch in length and it can be easily shortened to fit any pool area. All posts and screws are made of stainless steel hardware which will not rust or corrode. This fence has polymer sleeves which allow for stable installation and deck protection.

This kid safety fence comes with all the hardware, measuring template, instructions, and you‘ll also get free installation video. A rotary hammer drill is required for installation.

Things We Liked


  • ​Anti-climbing mesh construction
  • ​Easily removed and re-installed
  • ​Quality and durable materials
  • ​This fencing kit has a 5-year warranty.

Things We Didn't Like


  • If you don’t have the drill and the drill guide, you’ll need to rent one

Price:

$$


Editor Rating:

4.3/5

Pool Fence by EZ-Guard 4' 12'

Sentry Safety DIY Pool Fence by EZ-Guard comes pre-assembled in twelve foot sections with the poles three feet apart. This makes the installation process easier as you don’t need to measure and cut the fence to the length you need. These, and its other features, make it one of the best pool safety fences in this list.

All you have to do is drill the holes into the pool deck. Once the holes are drilled, simply insert the fence poles into the holes. The installation requires a ½” minimum rotary hammer drill with a standard ⅝” long shaft masonry drill bit which is NOT included.

This fence is built to last. It is made of a UV resistant interwoven fiberglass to prevent fading from the sun. It is also resistant to chlorine and other pool chemicals. The powder coated aluminum poles are completely rust proof.

Sentry Safety Fence pool is easy to remove, roll up and you can cover the holes with plastic sleeve caps when the fence is not in use. The instructions provided are simple to follow and will save you the time and hassle for both installation and later use.

You can use a hook and eye on the top of the last pole on each side attached to a wall to pull it tight. Sentry Safety Fence has no finger or toes holes, which completely eliminates the risk of children climbing on the fencing.

So, although nothing ever beats adult supervision, you can be fairly certain that your kids will be safe with this fence installed.

Things We Liked


  • ​Ideal for kids’ protection
  • ​Easily removed when not needed and reinserted
  • ​Quality and weather resistant materials
  • ​Elegant appearance with 4 colors to choose from

Things We Didn't Like


  • Those of you without drilling experience or tools will have to ask for or hire help

Price:

$$


Editor Rating:

4.2/5


Classic Guard Swimming Pool Fence is a removable mesh pool fence designed specifically for an easy DIY homeowner installation. It provides a barrier around residential swimming pools for toddlers, young children, and even your pets.

It comes in portable sections with poles pre-attached along with all the materials you need to easily construct your fence. The sections are 12 feet long and 4 feet tall. The fence has no finger or toe holes in the mesh for the kids to climb thus making it reliable and safe.

Classic Guard is an original in-ground pool fence design with powder coated black aluminum and made of durable UV lining and tear resistant mesh. These materials are made to stand up to weather and time as aluminum is a premium material which won’t rust or corrode.

The mesh is also UV resistant and it will withstand the blazing sun. The top and bottom come with double-sided protection by means of multi-stitched fencing material. This will prevent any possible threading of the fence at its edges.

Classic Guard Swimming Pool Fence 4 Feet Tall and 12 Feet Long

Any section of the fence can be easily and quickly altered to fit a pool or any other intended area. You can add poles to make more changes in direction of the fence and that goes for each pole. You can also split sections to use the fence in other areas, go up steps, create openings or end a fence section wherever you want. You will need to buy the gate separately, though.

Classic Guard comes exclusively in all black mesh, pole, and lining. Black is the most transparent of the meshes as when light hits a black mesh, no colors are reflected, which makes objects behind the mesh visible. This makes Classic Guard the best removable pool fence to keep the kids safe but also do justice to your pools, backyards and patios.

Things We Liked


  • ​Weather resistant materials
  • ​Easy to change the direction of the fence any way you want
  • ​Easy to change the direction of the fence any way you want
  • ​Elegant design with safety in mind

Things We Didn't Like


  • You need to allow for additional costs if you don’t have your own drill

Price:

$$


Editor Rating:

4.1/5


Protect-A-Pool Fence Base Kit features attractive fencing which adds to your kids’ safety and keeps toys, balls and floats within the pool. This fencing system will fit most popular above ground pools and can be purchased in only as many sections as needed.

The number of fence sections on your pool will vary based on the pool size, shape and manufacturer as well as decks and ladders. One fence section covers one pool top seat or top rail, or the distance between two pool uprights.

To determine the number of kits required, please refer to list on the manufacturer’s site. Every installation will require one base kit. Protect-A-Pool Fence Base Kit includes two end posts; one to start the installation and one to complete the installation.

Protect-A-Pool Fence Base Kit A - 8 Section Base Kit

The convenient modular packaging allows you to buy two types of add-on kits with additional two or three sections. This is perfect as it allows you to buy the exact number of sections for your pool.

Protect-A-Pool Fence for above ground pools is designed to meet the ANSI/NSPI Barrier Code for Above-ground/On-ground swimming pools. It is not designed as a handrail for decking and does not meet handrail codes. So, do not lean against the fence as it’s not designed to handle the weight of an adult person. It’s there to protect the kids and to keep the pool toys, balls and floats in the pool.

Available in white color and made of maintenance-free resin, Protect-A-Pool Fence includes all the parts and the hardware you need to mount the fence yourself with common tools and a little patience. Just follow the instructions in the user manual and the installation will be easy and hassle-free,

In our pool fence reviews, this is the best pool fence for above ground pools. It is a convenient and affordable DIY fence which will increase the general safety of your pool and make it look even prettier.

Things We Liked


  • ​Fits most above ground pools
  • ​Weather resistant materials
  • Modular packaging saves you money on extra sections
  • ​Easy DIY with no heavy drilling necessary

Things We Didn't Like


  • The self-tapping screws provided may need to be replaced by stronger ones

Price:

$$$


Laurie S.

As a multi home owner for 15 years I’ve tried out a ton of pool products and methods and have found out the best ones that work for me.

I love helping out other people with real, honest advice and spending time with my family. If you have any questions please don’t hesitate to contact me in the about or through a comment.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: